Abstract
-
Objective
Healthcare providers frequently spend excessive time attempting to identify a pulse and may have difficulty accurately confirming its presence. Point-of-care carotid artery ultrasonography has been suggested as a potential alternative to manual palpation. This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of manual palpation, 2D carotid ultrasonography, and rapid increases in end-tidal carbon dioxide (EtCO2) levels for determining the return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) in patients with cardiac arrest presenting to an emergency department.
-
Methods
This was a single-center, prospective, observational study. Nontraumatic adult patients in cardiopulmonary arrest who were brought to the emergency department were included. After cardiac arrest was identified, the following data were recorded: initial arrest rhythm, ultrasonographic and manual pulse assessments, EtCO2 levels, resuscitation duration, and post-ROSC vital signs. The team leader’s judgment was used for ROSC adjudication and served as the reference standard.
-
Results
The investigation included 88 patients who underwent a total of 642 cycles of cardiopulmonary resuscitation. The area under the curve (AUC) values for 2D carotid ultrasonography, EtCO2, and manual palpation were 0.974, 0.802, and 0.862, respectively (all P<0.001). In pairwise AUC comparisons, ultrasonography differed significantly from manual palpation (P=0.001) and EtCO2 (P<0.001), whereas manual palpation and EtCO2 did not differ significantly (P=0.167). Bedside ultrasonography for detecting a carotid pulse had a sensitivity of 93.8% and a specificity of 100%.
-
Conclusion
These findings suggest that 2D carotid ultrasonography can be effectively used to detect a pulse in patients with cardiopulmonary arrest.
-
Keywords: Ultrasonography; Capnography; Cardiopulmonary resuscitation; Return of spontaneous circulation; Cardiopulmonary arrest
Capsule Summary
What is already known
Healthcare providers often face challenges in accurately and quickly identifying a pulse during cardiac arrest. Manual palpation and end-tidal carbon dioxide monitoring are commonly used but may have limitations in detecting the return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC).
What is new in the current study
This study demonstrates that 2D carotid ultrasonography is highly sensitive (93.8%) and specific (100%) for detecting ROSC during cardiopulmonary resuscitation. It was also the only method that independently identified ROSC in some cases where other techniques failed, suggesting that it may be a more reliable tool for pulse assessment in patients with cardiac arrest.
INTRODUCTION
The annual incidence of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) in Europe ranges from 67 to 170 cases per 100,000 inhabitants. The rate of achieving return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) after OHCA is 10.5% [
1,
2].
Current guidelines emphasize the importance of delivering chest compressions with minimal interruptions and providing early defibrillation [
2]. Although a pulse check is recommended between cycles of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), no reference standard exists for determining the presence of a pulse. Recognition of carotid artery pulselessness by lay rescuers with basic CPR training is often time-consuming and highly inaccurate [
3]. In addition, healthcare providers frequently spend excessive time attempting to identify a pulse and may struggle to accurately confirm its presence [
4].
Chest compressions can cause various complications, including rib fractures, sternal fractures, internal organ injury, and hemorrhage. In addition, although adrenaline is beneficial in cardiac arrest, it can decrease cerebral and carotid perfusion, thereby reducing oxygen delivery to vital organs. Therefore, administering adrenaline via intravenous push could be detrimental if the patient has a detectable pulse [
5]. To reduce these complications, it is crucial to accurately determine whether a patient is in cardiac arrest. Several studies have shown that prolonged pulse detection times during manual palpation lead to longer interruptions in chest compressions, adversely impacting patient survival rates [
6]. Therefore, minimizing interruptions is of paramount importance. A sudden rise in end-tidal carbon dioxide (EtCO
2) is an accurate indicator of ROSC and can be used to reduce these interruptions. However, while a sudden increase in EtCO
2 exhibits high specificity, its sensitivity is limited [
7].
A case series has shown that a pulse may be undetectable in some patients by manual palpation but detectable using bedside 2D carotid ultrasonography [
8]. To prevent unnecessary complications and prolonged interruptions in chest compressions, ultrasonography and EtCO
2 monitoring can be used in conjunction with manual palpation to identify ROSC. The objective of this study was to assess the effectiveness of manual pulse palpation, bedside 2D carotid ultrasonography, and EtCO
2 levels for determining ROSC in patients with cardiopulmonary arrest in the emergency department (ED).
METHODS
Ethics statement
The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Health Sciences University Kocaeli Derince Training and Research Hospital (No. 2021-115). Written informed consent was obtained from each participant’s first-degree relative. All study procedures were conducted in accordance with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki.
Study design, setting, and participants
This was a single-center, prospective, observational study conducted between October 2021 and March 2022 at a tertiary care center with more than 300,000 ED visits annually. The study was conducted by 12 emergency medicine residents and six emergency medicine specialists, all of whom had completed the basic emergency ultrasound course provided by the Emergency Medicine Association of Turkiye (TATD) Ultrasonography Working Group. All participants had at least 1 year of experience performing basic emergency ultrasonography and voluntarily agreed to participate in the study. At the study center, ultrasonography is used in all critical care units by emergency medicine specialists and residents, and approximately one resuscitation procedure is performed per day by emergency medicine specialists together with third- and fourth-year residents.
The study included patients aged ≥18 years who experienced cardiopulmonary arrest. The following individuals were excluded from the study: (1) pregnant patients; (2) patients with traumatic cardiopulmonary arrest; (3) patients with missing data due to technical problems with the capnometer; (4) patients for whom written consent could not be obtained from relatives; and (5) patients in whom an elevation in EtCO
2 could be misinterpreted due to advanced chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) [
9].
Study protocol
Once cardiac arrest was identified, all assessments and diagnostic procedures were initiated immediately. The following data were recorded: initial arrest rhythm observed in the ED, resuscitation duration, vital signs after ROSC, comorbidities, whether manual or mechanical chest compressions were used, EtCO
2 levels, and the time from the first chest compression to the first ROSC. Ultrasonographic and manual pulse assessments were performed by different physicians. The Mylab Gamma ultrasound device (Esaote) with an SL1543 linear array transducer (3–13 MHz; Esaote) was used. The transducer was placed transversely over the carotid artery and internal jugular vein, with the marker pointing to the physician’s left, lateral to the trachea and medial to the sternocleidomastoid muscle, at the midpoint between the tragus and the sternal notch. A 2D image was obtained. A pulse was considered present on ultrasound when carotid artery pulsation was visualized and compression was seen only in the internal jugular vein. A pulse was considered absent when compression was evident in both vessels and no carotid pulsation was observed.
Fig. 1 illustrates accurate positioning of the ultrasound probe, compression of the internal jugular vein, and lack of compression of the carotid artery in a simulated patient.
EtCO
2 was measured using the mainstream method (BSM-3500 Bedside Monitor, Nihon Kohden). Continuous EtCO
2 monitoring was performed throughout resuscitation, with values recorded every 2 minutes during the pulse check phase. A sudden rise in EtCO
2 levels was considered indicative of a pulse and was quantified as an increase of more than 10 mmHg from the baseline EtCO
2 value, consistent with common interpretation in recent advanced cardiovascular life support (ACLS) guidance [
1]. The three assessors (manual palpation, ultrasonography, and EtCO
2) were blinded to one another’s findings, and each initial assessment was performed independently. However, the team leader (an emergency medicine specialist), who made the final determination regarding ROSC, was not blinded to these modalities. Pulse checks did not exceed 10 seconds. ROSC was defined as the sustained return of spontaneous palpable pulse or sonographically detectable pulsatile carotid flow, accompanied by a sudden increase in EtCO
2 level or other clinical signs of circulation, permitting at least 10 seconds without chest compressions, in accordance with the 2021 European Resuscitation Council Guidelines. Re-arrest events were recorded and contributed to the total number of CPR episodes and cycles; however, the primary outcome was the initial detection of ROSC. The team leader’s final determination of ROSC was based on careful review of all available data, including manual palpation, 2D carotid ultrasonography, and EtCO
2 levels. The criteria for ROSC were guided by the 2021 European Resuscitation Council Guidelines, which define ROSC based on clinical and physiological signs such as waking, purposeful movement, an arterial waveform, or a sudden rise in EtCO
2. The team leader’s final determination was used as the reference standard.
Outcome measures
The primary outcome was the identification of ROSC during each pulse check cycle, as adjudicated by the team leader. The primary analysis compared the diagnostic performance of the three index modalities (manual pulse palpation, carotid ultrasonography, and EtCO2) for detecting ROSC.
Statistical analysis
Statistical analyses were performed using IBM SPSS ver. 22.0 (IBM Corp) and RStudio ver. 2023.09.1+494 (Posit). For the combined receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve and DeLong method comparisons, jamovi ver. 2.6.44 (The jamovi project) was used. Data normality was assessed using the Shapiro-Wilk test. Continuous variables are presented as mean±standard deviation or median (interquartile range), as appropriate, whereas categorical variables are expressed as frequency (percentage). The chi-square test was used to compare categorical data between independent groups. The independent-samples t-test was employed for normally distributed continuous variables, whereas the Mann-Whitney U-test was used for non-normally distributed data. The Fleiss κ was used to assess agreement among the three pulse check methods, while the Cohen κ was utilized to assess agreement between pairs.
Pairwise comparisons of sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) across diagnostic modalities were performed using the exact McNemar test for paired binary data, since all diagnostic methods were applied to the same patients. For all analyses, a two-sided P-value of <0.05 was considered to indicate statistical significance.
An
a priori power analysis was performed using G*Power ver. 3.1.9.7 (University of Düsseldorf) to estimate the required sample size, based on data reported by Zengin et al. [
10], who compared manual pulse palpation with cardiac ultrasonography and Doppler ultrasonography for detecting ROSC in patients with cardiopulmonary arrest. Specifically, they evaluated the agreement between bedside 2D carotid ultrasonography and manual palpation as indicators of ROSC. Using a significance level of α=0.05 and power of 0.80, the minimum required sample size to detect a statistically significant agreement (with the Cohen κ) was calculated as 75.
RESULTS
A total of 136 patients with cardiac arrest were screened for inclusion. Forty-eight patients were excluded for various reasons, resulting in 88 patients being included in the analysis. ROSC was achieved in 49 patients (55.7%) in the ED. CPR was performed for recurrent cardiopulmonary arrest in 8 patients (9.1%). Overall, 88 patients underwent 102 CPR episodes, comprising a total of 642 CPR cycles during the study period.
Fig. 2 presents a flow diagram summarizing the study.
The demographic characteristics of the patients are summarized in
Table 1. Asystole was the predominant initial rhythm, followed by pulseless electrical activity. A statistically significant association was found between the location of cardiac arrest and the initial rhythm (P=0.012).
Pulse detection occurred in 67.2% of ROSC events based on an abrupt increase in EtCO
2. EtCO
2 values differed significantly between patients with and without ROSC (P<0.001). ROSC was detected in six patients (10.3%) exclusively by bedside 2D carotid ultrasonography; neither manual palpation nor EtCO₂ monitoring alone identified any ROSC event. The diagnostic performance of the three pulse check methods was evaluated using ROC analysis, and the combined ROC curves are presented in
Fig. 3. Pairwise AUC comparisons showed significant differences for 2D carotid ultrasonography versus manual palpation (P=0.001) and ultrasonography versus EtCO
2 (P<0.001), whereas the comparison between manual palpation and EtCO
2 did not exhibit a significant difference (P=0.167). Pairwise comparisons are summarized in
Table 2. Pairwise comparisons of diagnostic performance metrics were performed using the exact McNemar test for paired proportions. Sensitivity did not differ significantly among ultrasonography, manual palpation, and EtCO
2 (all P>0.999). NPV was significantly higher for ultrasonography than for manual palpation (P=0.004) and EtCO
2 (P<0.001), whereas no significant difference was observed between manual palpation and EtCO
2 (P=0.680). Specificity and PPV did not differ significantly among modalities (all P>0.05). The diagnostic performance of the three approaches is shown in
Table 3.
Interrater agreement among the three pulse check methods was substantial, with a Fleiss κ of 0.74 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.70–0.79). Pairwise Cohen κ values also indicated substantial agreement: 0.74 (95% CI, 0.51–0.95) for bedside carotid 2D ultrasonography and manual palpation; 0.74 (95% CI, 0.64–0.84) for bedside carotid 2D ultrasonography and EtCO2; and 0.69 (95% CI, 0.57–0.81) for manual palpation and EtCO2.
DISCUSSION
Most recent guidelines recommend using arterial blood pressure or EtCO
2, when feasible, to monitor and optimize the quality of CPR. However, arterial blood pressure measurement is invasive and time-consuming. A previous study reported a mean arterial catheter insertion time of 208 seconds, with placement unsuccessful in 16.7% of patients [
11]. Therefore, bedside 2D carotid ultrasonography, as a rapid and non-invasive technique, may be advantageous for identifying ROSC during resuscitation. Although earlier ACLS guidance did not definitively establish its effectiveness, the investigation of ultrasound for patient evaluation is recommended in a manner that minimizes interruptions to CPR [
2].
In this study, ROSC was identified in six CPR episodes (5.9%) exclusively by bedside 2D carotid ultrasonography. Neither EtCO2 nor manual palpation was the sole technique to identify any instances of ROSC. In addition, ROSC was identified by both manual palpation and an abrupt rise in EtCO2 in three episodes (2.8%) but was not identified using bedside 2D carotid ultrasonography. These findings suggest that bedside 2D carotid ultrasonography is a highly efficient, readily available, and non-invasive technique for detecting ROSC in patients with cardiac arrest.
Sheak et al. [
12] reported that patients with ROSC had a mean EtCO
2 level of 34.5±4.0 mmHg, whereas those without ROSC had a mean EtCO
2 level of 23.1±12.9 mmHg. The mean EtCO
2 levels among patients with cardiac arrest and those with ROSC in this study were consistent with these prior findings. To reduce potential selection bias, patients with severe COPD were excluded from our study, based on prior reports of higher EtCO
2 levels in patients with respiratory causes of cardiac arrest [
13,
14].
In prehospital settings, nonshockable rhythms are the most common initial rhythms in cardiac arrest [
10,
15,
16]. However, in this study, in contrast to prior reports, shockable rhythms were more frequently observed as the initial rhythm among patients with in-hospital cardiac arrest than among those with OHCA. A plausible explanation is that shockable rhythms in the prehospital setting may have deteriorated to asystole by the time patients arrived at the ED. This discrepancy suggests that some OHCA patients with an initial shockable rhythm may convert to asystole before ED arrival, underscoring the importance of prompt CPR and early defibrillation in OHCA settings.
Prior research has suggested that Doppler ultrasonography may offer advantages over manual palpation in patients with cardiac arrest. In a series of four cardiac arrest cases, point-of-care ultrasound detected a pulse in two patients in whom manual palpation was unsuccessful, leading to changes in patient management [
8]. In another study, 46 physicians were asked to assess the presence of a pulse using prerecorded 2D carotid ultrasound videos from patients who had undergone cardiopulmonary bypass surgery. The sensitivity and specificity of 2D ultrasonography for identifying the presence or absence of a pulse were similar to those of manual palpation [
17]. In the present study, the sensitivity and specificity of 2D carotid ultrasonography were exceptionally high. These findings suggest that pulse detection may be improved by using 2D carotid ultrasonography in conjunction with manual palpation and abrupt increases in EtCO
2 levels.
Özlü et al. [
18] reported that carotid artery ultrasonography for pulse checks had higher sensitivity and specificity than manual palpation. Similarly, the present study found comparable specificity across the three pulse check methods, but bedside 2D carotid ultrasonography had numerically higher sensitivity than the other two modalities. Nevertheless, pulse assessment using an arterial line or transesophageal echocardiography may provide greater accuracy. However, these approaches are often impractical, particularly during the first minutes of cardiac arrest in the ED; accordingly, in both studies, pulse assessment was not performed using these methods.
Limitations
This study had several limitations. First, the sample size was limited, and the study was conducted at a single center; therefore, the findings may not be generalizable. Second, while the study excluded patients in whom elevated EtCO2 could be misinterpreted due to COPD, other factors may still have influenced EtCO2 levels. Nevertheless, the team leader determined the presence of a pulse by carefully integrating all available data, and patients were not managed based solely on EtCO2 values, in accordance with guideline recommendations. However, because the team leader’s ROSC determination was used as the reference standard, diagnostic accuracy may have been overestimated. Third, although 2D carotid ultrasonography showed high sensitivity for detecting pulsatile flow, the study did not evaluate whether minimal carotid flow reflects adequate cerebral perfusion. Therefore, it remains unclear whether such findings alone are sufficient to confirm clinically meaningful ROSC. Future research should examine the correlations of sonographically detected pulsatile flow with markers of adequate end-organ perfusion and patient-centered outcomes. Fourth, the team leader responsible for the final ROSC determination was not blinded to any of the modalities. Although this approach reflects real-world clinical integration of multiple data sources, it may have introduced observer bias in the final ROSC adjudication. Finally, the analysis focused on initial ROSC detection and did not specifically assess whether ROSC was sustained or transient.
Conclusions
This study revealed that bedside 2D carotid ultrasonography was highly effective for detecting a pulse in patients with cardiopulmonary arrest compared with manual palpation and an abrupt increase in EtCO2. Therefore, bedside 2D carotid ultrasonography may be used in conjunction with manual palpation and EtCO2 monitoring.
NOTES
-
Author contributions
Conceptualization: all authors; Data curation: AG, SK, AEO, ES, EA; Formal analysis: HCH, ES; Investigation: SK, AG, EA, AES; Methodology: HCH, AES, AG; Supervision: HCH, AEO; Visualization: SK, EA, ES; Writing–original draft: HCH, AEO, ES; Writing–review & editing: all authors. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
-
Conflicts of interest
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.
-
Funding
The authors received no financial support for this study.
-
Data availability
The data analyzed in this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
Fig. 1.Evaluation of return of spontaneous circulation with 2D ultrasound. (A) Placement of the ultrasound probe. (B) Absence of compression in the carotid artery (asterisks) of a simulated patient. (C) Compression of the internal jugular vein (daggers). The patient provided informed consent for publication of the clinical images.
Fig. 2.Study flow diagram. CPR, cardiopulmonary resuscitation; EtCO2, end-tidal carbon dioxide.
Fig. 3.Combined receiver operating characteristic curves of 2D carotid ultrasonography, end-tidal carbon dioxide (EtCO2), and manual palpation. AUC, area under the curve; CI, confidence interval.
Table 1.Characteristics of study participants (n=88)
Table 1.
|
Characteristic |
Value |
|
Age (yr) |
72 (60–84) |
|
Male sex |
56 (63.6) |
|
Comorbidity |
|
|
Hypertension |
52 (59.1) |
|
Diabetes mellitus |
26 (29.5) |
|
Coronary artery disease |
43 (48.9) |
|
Cerebrovascular disease |
6 (6.8) |
|
Chronic renal disease |
7 (8.0) |
|
Malignancy |
17 (19.3) |
|
Mild-to-moderate COPD |
14 (15.9) |
|
Other |
17 (19.3) |
|
First SBP after ROSC (mmHg) |
105 (57–145) |
|
First DBP after ROSC (mmHg) |
60 (45–85) |
|
ROSC lead time (min) |
6 (4–8) |
|
CPR method |
|
|
Manual CPR |
17 (19.3) |
|
Mechanical CPR |
71 (80.7) |
|
Reason for stopping CPR |
|
|
ROSC |
49 (55.7) |
|
No ROSC |
39 (44.3) |
|
Location of cardiac arrest |
|
|
OHCA |
53 (60.2) |
|
IHCA |
35 (39.8) |
|
Initial ECG rhythm |
|
|
Asystole |
59 (67.0) |
|
PEA |
21 (23.9) |
|
VT |
2 (2.3) |
|
VF |
6 (6.8) |
Table 2.Pairwise AUC comparisons between modalities
Table 2.
|
Comparison |
AUC differencea)
|
95% CI |
P-value |
|
Ultrasonography vs. manual palpation |
0.112 |
0.044 to 0.180 |
0.001 |
|
Ultrasonography vs. EtCO2
|
0.172 |
0.103 to 0.241 |
<0.001 |
|
Manual palpation vs. EtCO2
|
0.060 |
−0.025 to 0.144 |
0.167 |
Table 3.Diagnostic accuracy of pulse check methods
Table 3.
|
Variable |
Ultrasonography |
Manual palpation |
EtCO2
|
|
Sensitivity (95% CI) (%) |
93.8 (85.6–98.9) |
72.4 (59.1–83.3) |
67.2 (53.7–79.0) |
|
Specificity (95% CI) (%) |
100 (99.4–100) |
100 (99.4–100) |
100 (99.4–100) |
|
PPV (95% CI) (%) |
100 (NA–100) |
100 (NA–100) |
100 (NA–100) |
|
NPV (95% CI) (%) |
99.5 (98.5–99.8) |
97.3 (96.0–98.2) |
96.9 (95.4–98.2) |
REFERENCES
- 1. Gräsner JT, Herlitz J, Tjelmeland IB, et al. European Resuscitation Council Guidelines 2021: epidemiology of cardiac arrest in Europe. Resuscitation 2021;161:61-79.
- 2. Virani SS, Alonso A, Aparicio HJ, et al. Heart disease and stroke statistics: 2021 update: a report from the American Heart Association. Circulation 2021;143:e254-743.
- 3. Suzuki K, Sakaniwa R, Endo N, et al. Accuracy of breathing and radial pulse assessment by non-medical persons: an observational cross-sectional study. Sci Rep 2023;13:1800.
- 4. Ochoa FJ, Ramalle-Gómara E, Carpintero JM, García A, Saralegui I. Competence of health professionals to check the carotid pulse. Resuscitation 1998;37:173-5.
- 5. Wiedermann FJ, Stichlberger M, Lederer W. Is epinephrine during cardiac arrest associated with worse outcomes in resuscitated patients? Effect of vasopressin and catecholamines on the migration of leukocytes. Crit Care 2015;19:120.
- 6. Badra K, Coutin A, Simard R, Pinto R, Lee JS, Chenkin J. The POCUS pulse check: a randomized controlled crossover study comparing pulse detection by palpation versus by point-of-care ultrasound. Resuscitation 2019;139:17-23.
- 7. Lui CT, Poon KM, Tsui KL. Abrupt rise of end tidal carbon dioxide level was a specific but non-sensitive marker of return of spontaneous circulation in patient with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. Resuscitation 2016;104:53-8.
- 8. Simard RD, Unger AG, Betz M, Wu A, Chenkin J. The POCUS pulse check: a case series on a novel method for determining the presence of a pulse using point-of-care ultrasound. J Emerg Med 2019;56:674-9.
- 9. Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease (GOLD). Archived reports [Internet]. GOLD; [cited 2024 Aug 5]. Available from: https://goldcopd.org/archived-reports/
- 10. Zengin S, Gümüşboğa H, Sabak M, Eren ŞH, Altunbas G, Al B. Comparison of manual pulse palpation, cardiac ultrasonography and Doppler ultrasonography to check the pulse in cardiopulmonary arrest patients. Resuscitation 2018;133:59-64.
- 11. Cohen AL, Li T, Becker LB, et al. Femoral artery Doppler ultrasound is more accurate than manual palpation for pulse detection in cardiac arrest. Resuscitation 2022;173:156-65.
- 12. Sheak KR, Wiebe DJ, Leary M, et al. Quantitative relationship between end-tidal carbon dioxide and CPR quality during both in-hospital and out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. Resuscitation 2015;89:149-54.
- 13. Grmec S, Lah K, Tusek-Bunc K. Difference in end-tidal CO2 between asphyxia cardiac arrest and ventricular fibrillation/pulseless ventricular tachycardia cardiac arrest in the prehospital setting. Crit Care 2003;7:R139-44.
- 14. Heradstveit BE, Sunde K, Sunde GA, Wentzel-Larsen T, Heltne JK. Factors complicating interpretation of capnography during advanced life support in cardiac arrest: a clinical retrospective study in 575 patients. Resuscitation 2012;83:813-8.
- 15. Gaspari R, Weekes A, Adhikari S, et al. Emergency department point-of-care ultrasound in out-of-hospital and in-ED cardiac arrest. Resuscitation 2016;109:33-9.
- 16. Salen P, Melniker L, Chooljian C, et al. Does the presence or absence of sonographically identified cardiac activity predict resuscitation outcomes of cardiac arrest patients? Am J Emerg Med 2005;23:459-62.
- 17. Sanchez S, Miller M, Asha S. Assessing the validity of two-dimensional carotid ultrasound to detect the presence and absence of a pulse. Resuscitation 2020;157:67-73.
- 18. Özlü S, Bilgin S, Yamanoglu A, et al. Comparison of carotid artery ultrasound and manual method for pulse check in cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Am J Emerg Med 2023;70:157-62.